Monday, September 1, 2008

Two weeks with Kindle…survey says “thumbs up”

So I’m back from my annual two-week “unplugged” vacation where I catchup on my non-work reading, and this year I decided to take the plunge and get an Amazon Kindle. I read about 8 books on Kindle (+5 print books) during my 2 weeks away, and here’s my initial impressions of using it.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:An outstanding replacement for mass-market and most trade paperbacks and many hardbacks. Not a replacement for technical books, articles, arbitrary PDFs, etc. A good rule of thumb seems to be that a text that could be reasonably rendered using a simple markup format like Pod or Javadoc will read well on the Kindle. Books with lots of graphs/tables/figures, complex layout, or where typography matters, will not read well.


  • User experience of browsing, buying books, etc. is nicely integrated, though browsing the Kindle Store on the device itself is a little like browsing Web 1.0 pages on a black-and-white, 640×480 computer over slow dialup. (The omission of Wifi is baffling.)

  • Pricing model for books is defensible: bestsellers $10 (typically that’s less than half price of the print hardback), mass market paperbacks around $6, older titles as low as $3. If you consider the device a sunk cost, it often makes good economic sense to buy a Kindle edition, even compared to buying a used print copy.

  • The user experience of actually reading is great. It’s lighter and easier to hold than even a mass-market paperback.

  • I’m often in the middle of several books at a time. Flipping among them is trivial and your bookmarks are automatically remembered. This will make me read more, by eliminating the minor inconvenience of getting my butt out of the chair to swap out books.

  • Most important by far: I traveled with 10.3 ounces, rather than about 15 pounds. With per-bag luggage fees, carry-on limits, and just the fact that I like to travel light, this trumps virtually every weakness of the device.


  • I’ve been carping about the lack of PDF support. (Amazon’s PDF “converter” is terrible, yielding mostly-unusable versions of anything that’s not mostly text.) However, I’m beginning to come around to the fact that this device is a one-trick pony: it’s my non-work-documents reader. I’m looking at an iRex Iliad, which has a letter-size display that’s also touch sensitive, handles PDF’s, and allows annotations with a stylus, as a companion device for technical documents. In a sense, complaining that I can’t read letter-size technical articles on this device would be a bit like complaining that a mass-market paperback is not the right format for technical books.

  • Although you can change the font size while reading, apparently you can’t change the actual font. There’s evidently one sans-serif font (Helvetica) and one serif font (blockier than Times) on the device. They’re fine to read, but you lose any aesthetics of typography. This is fine if your reading material would otherwise have been mass-market paperback; it may be an annoying omission in other cases, especially for typography geeks like me.

  • Amazingly, while the table of contents of all books I purchased were hyperlinked, neither footnotes nor indices are. It doesn’t seem like this would be hard to do in a markup format (which is evidently what’s being used here,I assume something like DocBook as opposed to a page-description format).

  • The page-flip buttons are arranged in such a way that it’s easy to hit them by accident. A simple fix would be software-controllable configuration of what those buttons do (e.g. so I could disable the ones I don’t use, since the functionality on some buttons is redundant).

  • The scroll-wheel menus are awkward for “two-dimensional” GUI displays, which crop up occasionally when you’re browsing the Kindle Store on the device itself.

  • In general, the Store UI could be streamlined to minimize the number of (SLOW) wireless roundtrips and screen redraws when exploring a book title, reading reviews, etc. I assume a forthcoming software update will fix this.

  • As is well known, the selection of titles available for Kindle is a tiny fraction of the print title selection (though still a lot better than for any other ebook reader AFAIK). But if you read as much as I do, there’s always something worth having.

  • Why does this thing have an MP3 player (which I didn’t use, and for which there is no comparable “seamless” download experience, nor any UI) but not Wifi?  Who listens to music while reading?

  • The price is way too high ($360 currently) but I’m sure it’ll go down. I’d like to see these kinds of devices more widely adopted if only for the positive environmental implications. For now, it’s a luxury for those of us who read a whole lot and are willing to pay a premium for early adoption.

  • I’m not going to wring my hands over DRM right now; Apple’s iTunes Music Store eventually became DRM-free once there was a large established market for the product (which isn’t yet true of Kindle ebooks) and a seamless buyer experience (which largely is true of Kindle), so there’s no fundamental reason this couldn’t happen for ebooks.


  • I’m going to try running Amazon’s HTML-to-Kindle converter on the output of latex2html, which usually produces a very usable HTML version from LaTeX source. That might at least give me a way to read documents for which I have the LaTeX source.

  • I’d like to identify a “one-click” formatting pipeline for putting public domain etexts (eg from Project Gutenberg) on the Kindle. Anyone know of one?

  • I’d like to see the DRM extended to allow me to “loan” a Kindle book to another user not registered to my same account. During that time, the book would be unavailable on my Kindle until the other user “returns” it. My guess is this would dampen a lot of the fair-use handwringing and be a reasonable compromise. Note that the machinery for this already exists, since you can “return” a Kindle book you didn’t mean to purchase, causing it to be erased from your Kindle before your money is refunded. (Note that you can buy up to 6 Kindles registered on a single Amazon account, and titles can be shared among those.)

  • Similarly…I’d like to be able to “borrow” one of a fixed number of circulating e-copies of a book from, say, the San Francisco Public Library.  The New York Public Library and a few others currently do this for Mobipocket format (DRM’d) ebooks, but these can’t be read on Kindle (although a hack allows non-DRM’d Mobipocket format books to be read on Kindle).

  • The decision not to include Wifi (falling back to EVDO, iPhone-style) is baffling. In Mexico I had good Wifi access but no EVDO. At home, the EVDO bandwidth isn’t great and I’d rather use my home Wifi.

  • The UI is inconsistent and sometimes confusing. What’s a “clipping” vs. a “note” vs. a “hilight” vs. a “mark”? The navigation UI for these annotation-type things is not very graceful.

BOTTOM LINE: I like it and I’m keeping it. I probably will never travel without it; the extent to which it replaces print books (especially as I’m a big library borrower) for at-home and at-work reading remains to be seen.